Sam, Neal, and Bill befriend a pretty new transfer student, but soon fear of losing her to the popular crowd and try to win her over with a series of fun things they plan for her. Lindsay, Nick, Daniel, and Ken decide to get fake IDs so they can see a hot local band perform at a bar. However, after they go through the trouble of getting their IDs and getting into the bar, the group is stunned to find out who the hot local bands lead singer is.
WAR
79.5
Wins Above Replacement
“I'm with the Band” ranks #7 of 18 Freaks and Geeks episodes on the Humor Index, scoring 81.5 — Elite. The episode packs 82 scored jokes at 2.3 per minute, averaging 7.1 on craft and 6.9 on impact, with Sam landing the most laughs. Every joke is ranked below with its individual craft and impact scores.
Get weekly comedy rankings
Join comedy fans getting new analyses, score drops, and the funniest moments each week. Free, no spam.
Top Jokes
Lindsay · Kim: Lindsay: '...and the Who never even practice Teenage Wasteland.' Kim: 'Baba O'Riley.' Lindsay: 'What?' Kim: 'The name of the song is Baba O'Riley. It's on Who's Next?'
Lindsay Kim Setup/Punchline Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Jean · Lindsay · Sam · Harold: Jean: 'Lindsay, tell your brother what a beautiful body he has.' Lindsay: 'That is so stupid.' Jean, Harold insist. Lindsay finally: 'Sam... you have a beautiful body. You're an Adonis, a slab of beef... if I wasn't your sister, oh my God—' Jean: 'LINDSAY! Can it.'
Mr. Andopolis: Nick's dad: 'Nick, I really thought I could walk on the moon, but you just don't see any moon rocks around here, do ya?'
Nick: Nick: 'I'll be lucky if I get to be the guy who pushes the button that makes the riser go up. But I'm not even gonna be that guy. I'm not even gonna be that guy because I can't even keep a C+ average.'
Nick Dark/Subversive Escalation ★ Rewatch Callback Bill: Bill watching the couple: 'He should use his legs more. He's gonna throw out his back.'
Bill Deadpan/Understatement Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Callback All Jokes — 82 analyzed
Show all ↓ Hide ↑ Nick: Nick singing Rush loudly and badly out of key while playing along with the tape, fully committed and oblivious
Nick Character Comedy Visual Gag ★ Rewatch Sam · Mr. Fredricks: Sam tells the gym teacher 'You look a little bit like my grandpa.' Teacher replies: 'Oh, is your grandpa super cool?'
Student · Mr. Fredricks: Student: 'Jimmy Carter's a wimp.' Fredricks: 'Hey, can it, White.'
Coach Fredricks: Coach announces mandatory showers with wet-hair inspections starting today
Alan: 'Is Weir allowed to shower with us? 'Cause he's a woman.'
Alan Cringe/Discomfort Character Comedy Mr. Fredricks · Bill: Fredricks: 'Kiss the beam, you're on my team.' Then Bill's dangling helplessly on the rope: 'What do I look like, a freakin' Tarzan?'
Sam · Bill: Sam: 'Don't you think it's kinda weird that they want us to, you know... get naked?' Bill: 'It's not a burlesque show, Sam. They just want us to shower.'
Sam Bill Deadpan/Understatement Character Comedy Neal · Sam · Bill: Neal dangling on the rope says 'Stop lookin' up my shorts.' The others: 'Why would we? There's nothing to see.' Neal: 'There IS something to see.'
Alan · Neal: Bully to Neal: 'Hey Schweiber, you gonna show us your circumcision in the showers today?' Neal: 'Yeah. Take a number.'
Alan Neal Setup/Punchline Deadpan/Understatement ★ Rewatch Bill: Bill: 'I can't go up any farther, guys. How do I get back down?'
Bill Character Comedy Physical/Slapstick Drama Student · Sam · Others: Student doing an announcement for Oklahoma! complete with 'Yee-haw!' — other students visibly horrified and groaning: 'Oh, no!' 'No way.'
Nick · Drama Student: Nick to the drama student: 'Wow. You'd look good in that dress.' She responds: 'Thanks.'
Nick · Daniel: Nick: 'Yeah. Creation.' Daniel: 'No, we don't have a name.' Nick: 'Come on. I like that name.'
Daniel · Nick: Daniel: 'How about 3:15? I gotta fit in your mother.' Nick: 'You wanna sleep with my mom?' Daniel: 'Mm-hmm.'
Bill · Sam: Bill, suddenly self-aware: 'You know, to be honest, I don't smell so good. I could probably use a shower.' Sam: 'NO! We have to stick together!'
Bill: Bill: 'Hey, if we don't shower, then we ARE gonna stick together. You get it?'
Bill Wordplay/Pun Deadpan/Understatement Sam · Mr. Fredricks: Sam to Fredricks: 'Well... we didn't even sweat. Smell us.' Fredricks: 'You know, Weir, I'll put that on my To Do list.'
Sam · Mr. Fredricks: Sam successfully escapes the shower by claiming illness. Fredricks: 'Pick up the Academy Award on the way there, Weir. Sheesh.'
Mr. Fredricks · Neal: Fredricks then turns to Neal: 'Schweiber, put on some clothes. You look like a 50-year-old man.'
Sam · Bill: Sam: 'That guy's really into making guys shower.' Bill: 'Tell me about it.'
Sam Bill Irony/Sarcasm Deadpan/Understatement Mr. Andopolis: Nick's dad enters the basement to the chaos and says 'I take it the symphony's over.'
Ken: Ken mocking Mr. Andopolis's greeting as he leaves: '[Mocking voice] Ladies, gentlemen...' as soon as the door closes
Ken Irony/Sarcasm Character Comedy Nick · Lindsay: Lindsay hesitates about joining the others; Nick says 'Can't you just wait for me?' Others leave. Lindsay: 'Yeah, I'll wait.' Nick: 'Yeah?' That small exchange, then: 'This is Mission Control requesting permission to rock out.'
Nick Lindsay Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm ★ Rewatch Callback Mr. Andopolis: Nick's dad: 'I really thought that I could walk on the moon, but you just don't see any moon rocks around here, do ya?'
Mr. Andopolis: Nick's dad: 'Nick, I really thought I could walk on the moon, but you just don't see any moon rocks around here, do ya?'
Lindsay · Nick: Lindsay: 'Your mom cans her own vegetables?' — followed by a muffled scream from Nick in the next room
Nick · Lindsay: Nick: 'I should probably change out of these shorts first.' Lindsay: 'I think they look good.' Nick: 'It's just a lot easier for me to drum without fabric on my thighs.'
Sam: Sam gets hit in the face by an earth ball. 'That's it. I'm gonna die in gym class.'
Sam Physical/Slapstick Character Comedy Bill: Bill capitulates to showering: 'Yeah, and I can't say no to a long, luxurious shower.'
Bill Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm Sam · Bill: Sam: 'No! You can't!' [Bill defects] Sam: 'Oh, come on. Just one more day.' Bill: 'Would you quit being such a baby? Just close your eyes, and it'll be over before you know it.'
Sam Bill Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm Sam · Nude Classmate: A fully nude classmate approaches Sam in the locker room to ask casually about French class next year. Sam asks him to put on a towel. The guy: 'Why? Our bodies are merely a shell which conceal our heavenly souls. Try not to get too uptight. Auf Wiedersehen.'
Sam · Neal: Neal suddenly discovers he has chest hair: 'When did you get chest hair?' Neal: 'What? I have chest ha— Oh! Would you look at that?'
Sam Neal Character Comedy Setup/Punchline Bill: Bill, as if it's a practical swimming observation: 'It'll slow you down in the pool.'
Bill Deadpan/Understatement Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Neal: Neal: 'Oh shoot! I was gonna bring some cologne. I completely forgot.' — right before the towel-snapping bullies arrive
Neal Character Comedy Cringe/Discomfort Sam · Neal: The bullies attack the geeks with towels in the shower. Sam: 'OWW! I hope I can still have kids.' Neal: 'Come on. You got hit in the groin. You didn't have a hysterectomy.'
Sam Neal Setup/Punchline Cringe/Discomfort ★ Rewatch Mr. Fredricks: Fredricks to Sam, who has avoided showering again: 'Look at that head of hair, huh? You just get that cut? That is very stylish and very, very dry.'
Kim: Kim has a Gremlin. [As a car.]
Kim Visual Gag Character Comedy Lindsay: Nick: 'Yeah. When I was in the Mathletes, we did logarithms until we couldn't see straight.'
Lindsay Irony/Sarcasm Character Comedy Ken: After Nick tries to make the band practice more seriously, Ken says: 'Gee, this is really fun, guys. I'm glad we have a band.'
Ken Deadpan/Understatement Irony/Sarcasm Daniel: After Nick forces another run-through of 'Sunshine of Your Love': 'Well, that sucked. Royally.'
Daniel Deadpan/Understatement Irony/Sarcasm Daniel: Daniel exploding at Nick and Lindsay: 'You and Yoko here have turned music into school.'
Daniel Setup/Punchline Dark/Subversive ★ Rewatch Nick · Daniel: Nick: 'At least the marching band can play something right twice in a row!' Daniel: 'Rock 'n' roll don't come from your brain. It comes from your crotch. And if you ever got any, Mr. Cute Shorts, you'd know that.'
Nick Daniel Setup/Punchline Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Callback Nick · Daniel: Nick: 'Fine! I guess that means I quit.' Daniel: 'Fine! Quit!' Nick: 'Fine!' — then throws down drumsticks: 'You're not even good enough to be in Creation!'
Nick Daniel Escalation Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Callback Neal · Bill · Sam: The geeks watch a couple making out. Neal: 'What do they have that we don't?' Bill: 'Good bodies. So he can throw her over his shoulder.'
Bill: Bill watching the couple: 'He should use his legs more. He's gonna throw out his back.'
Bill Deadpan/Understatement Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Callback Neal · Sam: Neal: 'I don't know. My mom says women prefer guys with a good sense of humor.' Sam: 'But you're not very funny.' Neal: 'Screw you! I'm hilarious.'
Neal Sam Setup/Punchline Character Comedy Sam: Sam: 'Ooh, how witty. Get this guy on Hollywood Squares.'
Sam Irony/Sarcasm Deadpan/Understatement Sam · Neal · Bill: Sam: 'I overheard Todd Shellinger takes off his shirt when he makes out.' Neal: 'Why would he do that?' Bill: 'Why would anybody do that?' Sam: 'Probably to show off his chest hair. I know that's what I'm gonna do.'
Neal · Bill: Neal lists his chest hair role models: 'Selleck, Reynolds, Rockford.' Bill: 'Hey, what about Mork? He's got more hair on his hand than Sam has in his pits.'
Neal Bill Setup/Punchline Character Comedy Callback Neal: Neal: 'Hey, what about Mork? He's got more hair on his hand than Sam has in his pits.'
Neal Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm Sam · Bill: Sam: 'Will girls ever like us?' Bill: 'I think our best play is to go for the smart, sexy librarian type. You know, she's sweet and shy, but then she takes off her glasses and RROWF!'
Neal · Bill · Sam: Neal: 'Like Bailey on WKRP in Cincinnati.' Bill: 'Yup.' Sam: 'But Cindy Sanders is like a librarian type.' Neal: 'Yeah. Librarian for the Playboy Mansion.'
Sam: Sam, attempting a push-up: 'This push-up's too hard to push up.'
Sam Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement Lindsay: Lindsay sarcastically: 'God, how could I be so awful to suggest you actually play an entire song correctly all the way through? God knows Zeppelin only plays half of Stairway to Heaven, and the Who never even practice Teenage Wasteland.'
Lindsay Irony/Sarcasm Character Comedy Lindsay · Kim: Lindsay: '...and the Who never even practice Teenage Wasteland.' Kim: 'Baba O'Riley.' Lindsay: 'What?' Kim: 'The name of the song is Baba O'Riley. It's on Who's Next?'
Lindsay Kim Setup/Punchline Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Lindsay · Daniel: Lindsay: 'You sound just like his dad.' Daniel: 'Maybe his dad is right.'
Mark · Other Student · Coach: Two students having a Red-rum conversation right next to the coach: 'Yeah man, and this kid, he was like, Red-rum! Red-rum!' Other: 'Forget it man, Red-rum's murder backwards.' Coach: 'HEY! Come on. This ain't tea with the Queen.'
Sam · Unknown Man: Sam hiding in the bathroom stall. Mysterious voice: 'Hey, you know, it's a little easier if you sit down and drop your pants.'
Jean · Harold: Jean (Sam's mom) at dinner: 'Sam, you have a beautiful body.' Then turns to Harold: 'Doesn't he, Harold?' Harold: 'Yes. I just said he had a beautiful body.'
Coach Fredricks: Coach Fredricks to Sam's mom: 'You know how many men have seen me naked in my lifetime? A lot. Do you think I'm comfortable with it? No, but I live with it.'
Jean · Lindsay · Sam · Harold: Jean: 'Lindsay, tell your brother what a beautiful body he has.' Lindsay: 'That is so stupid.' Jean, Harold insist. Lindsay finally: 'Sam... you have a beautiful body. You're an Adonis, a slab of beef... if I wasn't your sister, oh my God—' Jean: 'LINDSAY! Can it.'
Paul (auditioning drummer): Previous auditioner to Nick at the Dimension audition: 'I never played on a drum kit this small before. I'm sure I'll be fine.'
Nick · Scott · Band Members: Nick, referring to his drum kit: 'The one I normally play on is a lot bigger.' Band member: 'Oh wow, really? How many pieces?' Nick: '29.' Others: 'Whoa! 29-piece kit.' First band member: 'What are you doing here? You should be auditioning us.'
Nick · Scott: Nick to the band: 'I saw you guys open for Jethro Tull at Cobo Hall last year. You guys blew them away.' Band member: 'Well, you must've been there Friday night, 'cause Saturday night we got booed off the stage.'
Scott · Nick: After Nick's disastrous audition, band member: 'Good. All right. Great job, man.' Nick: 'Cool. Thanks a lot.' Nick: 'What do you mean? That's it?' Band member: 'Yeah. Thanks a lot.' Nick: 'Hey, good luck with that 29-piecer, man. Maybe someday you'll knock it up to an even 30.'
Scott Nick Dark/Subversive Irony/Sarcasm ★ Rewatch Callback Scott: Scott's parting shot to Nick: 'Hey, good luck with that 29-piecer, man. Maybe someday you'll knock it up to an even 30.'
Scott Irony/Sarcasm Deadpan/Understatement ★ Rewatch Callback Nick: Nick describes his fantasy: playing a 10-minute solo, on a hydraulic riser that goes 'way up high.' 'I'm Peter Criss or something.'
Nick Character Comedy Dark/Subversive Nick: Nick: 'I'll be lucky if I get to be the guy who pushes the button that makes the riser go up. But I'm not even gonna be that guy. I'm not even gonna be that guy because I can't even keep a C+ average.'
Nick Dark/Subversive Escalation ★ Rewatch Callback Neal · Bill: Neal: 'What is wrong with them? Why do they think that hitting people with towels is so funny?' Bill (after a beat): 'If it wasn't us... [laughs] ...it would be kinda funny.'
Neal Bill Setup/Punchline Dark/Subversive ★ Rewatch Random Student · Neal: A random passing older student greets them: 'Afternoon, gentlemen.' Then: 'Hey, have you lost weight?' The geeks, still recovering: 'Shut up!'
Mr. Fredricks · Sam: Fredricks, seeing Sam finally showering: 'Nice pecs, Weir. You look like a flat-chested girl.'
Sam · Bullies: Sam: 'Well, I'm proud of my body.' Bullies (mockingly): 'Oh, he's proud of his body. Oh, he should be proud. Look at this.' [They throw him outside naked]
Mr. Fredricks · New Teacher: Fredricks, seemingly guilty/complicit in the Sam situation, suddenly turns to the new teacher beside him: 'So, uh, how long have you been teaching?' '2 months.' 'Do you like it?' 'I love it.' 'I love it too.'
Sam · Students: Sam is thrown out naked and runs across the school grounds. 'Streaker! Go, Sam! Go!'
Sam: Sam runs naked through the school hallway — the full streaking payoff
Sam Physical/Slapstick Escalation ★ Rewatch Callback Daniel: Band member: 'Hey, is Dimension gonna charge you for the pee stain you left on the drum seat?'
Daniel Dark/Subversive Character Comedy Nick · Kim · Lindsay: [Mouthing through window] Nick: 'Hey, Lindsay, we have to talk.' Kim mouthing back: 'You are such a slut.'
Neal · Sam: Neal: 'I'm pretty sure Cindy didn't see you [streaking]. And if she did, it was just with her peripheral vision.' Sam: 'You know, it wouldn't be bad if people saw my back. But my front's a whole other story.'
Neal Sam Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement Alan: Alan's parting shot: 'I heard they're bringing in the psychiatrist for all the kids who had to see you naked.'
Alan Setup/Punchline Cringe/Discomfort Sam · Girls · Alan: Girls cheering Sam as he walks by: 'There he is! Hey Sam, I heard you streaked! Way to go!' Alan, watching: 'You guys are losers and you always will be.' Sam's response: 'How come you're the one riding home with no friends?'
Neal: Neal to Sam: 'You're like a god. People are gonna worship you.'
Neal Irony/Sarcasm Character Comedy Nick: Nick alone in the basement playing along with the recording again — cheers on the tape — saying 'I play so much better when you're around.' Then: 'Hey, I want to play it again. Put more dry ice in the bucket.'
Nick Character Comedy Dark/Subversive ★ Rewatch Callback Top Episodes — Freaks and Geeks