Part 2 of 2. Dennis, Frank, and Dee find unique ways of coping with the apparent loss of their friends.
WAR
28.8
Wins Above Replacement
“Mac and Charlie Die (2)” ranks #171 of 177 It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia episodes on the Humor Index, scoring 68.0 — Mixed. The episode packs 56 scored jokes at 1.1 per minute, averaging 6.5 on craft and 6.5 on impact, with Charlie landing the most laughs. Every joke is ranked below with its individual craft and impact scores.
Get weekly comedy rankings
Join comedy fans getting new analyses, score drops, and the funniest moments each week. Free, no spam.
Top Jokes
Charlie · Mac: Charlie immediately agreeing to kill themselves: 'Great, let's kill ourselves. Let's do it.'
Charlie Mac Dark/Subversive Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Mac: Mac: 'Pawnshops are like international waters. Anything goes here.'
Mac Character Comedy Absurdist ★ Rewatch Mac · Charlie: Mac actually crashing the car instead of jumping out
Mac Charlie Physical/Slapstick Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Charlie: Charlie struggling with bindle physics: 'how do hobos fit all this stuff into a bandana?!'
Charlie Observational Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Charlie · Dee: Charlie's request that his ashes be made into tea and 'dranken by everyone'
All Jokes — 56 analyzed
Show all ↓ Hide ↑ Unknown Parole Officer · Charlie: Quote from police statement: father threatened to 'eat the living shit out of you'
Unknown Parole Officer · Charlie: Quote: 'rape you so hard the room would stink'
Unknown Parole Officer · Charlie · Mac: Quote: 'eat your butt and his son's butt in the stink until his stomach was full of... your butts'
Mac · Charlie · Unknown Officials: Mac and Charlie fighting over the microphone at a parole hearing
Mac: Objection! That's an objection, Your Honor. Move to strike!
Mac Character Comedy Absurdist Charlie · Mac: Charlie's plan to tell parole board about butt rape threats with excessive butt repetition
Charlie Mac Character Comedy Absurdist ★ Rewatch Callback Mac · Charlie: You're not going to say it exactly like that... Sure? That's a lot of butts.
Mac Charlie Observational Deadpan/Understatement ★ Rewatch Charlie: Yeah, I think all the butt madness is really going to sell it.
Charlie Absurdist Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Mac · Charlie: Mac wants to be hobos 'drifting from town to town, solving mysteries'
Charlie: Charlie struggling with bindle physics: 'how do hobos fit all this stuff into a bandana?!'
Charlie Observational Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Charlie · Mac: Charlie immediately agreeing to kill themselves: 'Great, let's kill ourselves. Let's do it.'
Charlie Mac Dark/Subversive Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Charlie: I'm going to grab a knife, I'm going to jab it into your neck, I'll yank it out. Then your blood's going to start going everywhere.
Mac · Charlie: If we were going to kill ourselves, it'd be awesome, right? Of course it would be with class!
Dee: Do you think it's for watching somebody poop? You think there's some perv coming in here to watch me make?
Dee Cringe/Discomfort Character Comedy Dennis: Dennis: 'It's very European. Europe leads the way in sexual exploration'
Frank: I could just picture a girl, and then, it's good.
Frank Character Comedy Cringe/Discomfort Dennis · Frank: Dennis: 'How's he going to do that with a dick in his mouth?'
Mac: Wait. That just kind of came out on its own. I barely pulled that.
Mac Visual Gag Cringe/Discomfort Mac: Man, you should really brush your teeth more because that is not normal.
Mac Observational Deadpan/Understatement Charlie: Okay, I got to go fill her a dick hole, bro.
Charlie Wordplay/Pun Character Comedy Charlie: Okay, I got to go fill her a dick hole, bro.
Charlie Wordplay/Pun Character Comedy Mac: You could've just opened it.
Mac Observational Physical/Slapstick Charlie · Mac: Charlie abandoning Mac at the last second before the car crash
Mac Character Comedy Reaction Beat Mac · Charlie: Mac actually crashing the car instead of jumping out
Mac Charlie Physical/Slapstick Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Charlie: Why didn't you jump out?
Charlie Observational Character Comedy Mac: I guess I was just going too fast. I was going too fast.
Mac Deadpan/Understatement Character Comedy Mac: Mac: 'Pawnshops are like international waters. Anything goes here.'
Mac Character Comedy Absurdist ★ Rewatch Mac: That car wreck, it scrambled your circuits, all right? You're losing your mind.
Mac Character Comedy Observational Mac · Pawnshop Owner: Mac asking pawnshop owner for something to 'annihilate any traces of a human being'
Charlie: Except for when we find the bride. That's a very important part of my plan.
Charlie Running Gag Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Callback Mac · Charlie: The grenade producing a pathetic small explosion
Mac · Charlie: That's it? Weird. That was totally lame. What a gyp.
Charlie · Mac: Charlie wearing the wedding dress while discussing plans
Charlie Mac Visual Gag Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Callback Mac: He's also wearing a wedding dress, though, and I'd like him to take it off.
Mac Visual Gag Running Gag ★ Rewatch Callback Frank · Dennis · Doorman: The elite sex party password being simply 'Orgy'
Dennis · Frank: The 'elite orgy' being a sad buffet with old people in underwear
Mac · Charlie: Mac and Charlie's dramatic suicide video message
Mac · Charlie: Dennis and Frank, if you're watching this, then we're already dead. Our lives were horrible. Horrible and sad, so we decided to end it all. Not me actually, my life was pretty sweet.
Dee · Dennis: The 'will' being titled 'List of demands'
Charlie · Dee: Charlie's request that his ashes be made into tea and 'dranken by everyone'
Mac · Dennis · Dee: Mac wanting to name first-born children Murphy 'because that was Robocop's name'
Dee · Dennis: They're people! They're lying people!
Mac · Charlie: You're not gonna be able to eat this hot dog. I'll suck it down.
Dennis: Dennis's passionate rant about not burning the duster
Dennis Character Comedy Escalation ★ Rewatch Dennis: I'm not gonna burn it! So, end of story, you know. Let's just move on.
Dennis Escalation Character Comedy Charlie: She watched an entire episode of Mama's Family and fell asleep.
Charlie Observational Character Comedy Dee: Animals. You're touching me. That doesn't... this isn't weird for you?
Dee Character Comedy Cringe/Discomfort Mac · Charlie: Mac and Charlie fighting over the last popper
Mac: When were you ever going to use nunchakus? Are you kidding me?
Mac Character Comedy Observational Jan: Do you know what this is like? Banging the chicks that you live with? It's terrible, man.
Jan Observational Character Comedy Jan: Here's the best part: I don't even know most of their names.
Jan Character Comedy Cringe/Discomfort Dee · Mac · Charlie: Dee demanding a 'new' 1997 Dodge Neon
Charlie: You got some beans on you, or what's up?
Charlie Running Gag Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Callback Frank · Charlie: Frank using Charlie as a ventriloquist dummy
Frank: I like you, too, Charlie. I like you, too, New Charlie.
Frank Character Comedy Cringe/Discomfort ★ Rewatch Top Episodes — It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia
