Tobias searches for meaning after splitting with Lindsay, only to find that old habits die hard.
Wordplay-heavy Tobias episode sustains 91.5 score through character-rooted irony across 44 jokes.
Directed by Mitchell Hurwitz, Troy Miller · Written by Dean Lorey, Jim Vallely
WAR
181
Wins Above Replacement
“A New Start” ranks #6 of 84 Arrested Development episodes on the Humor Index, scoring 99.9 — Elite. The episode packs 100 scored jokes at 3.0 per minute, averaging 7.9 on craft and 7.8 on impact, with Tobias landing the most laughs. Every joke is ranked below with its individual craft and impact scores.
Get weekly comedy rankings
Join comedy fans getting new analyses, score drops, and the funniest moments each week. Free, no spam.
Top Jokes
Tobias: Daddy needs to get his rocks off.
Tobias Character Comedy Wordplay/Pun ★ Rewatch John Beard · Tobias: How old is she? / I want to say 19? / But I like to think of her as 15.
Tobias: DeBrie, look, some people struggle with addiction. Other people are incapable of ever being nude. Everybody has something.
Tobias Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm ★ Rewatch Callback Tobias · DeBrie: Did you see my license plate, 'A-N-U-S-T-A-R-T'? / Did you see my StraightBait movie of the same name?
Tobias: I'm here to see my little girl. / I wanted to show her Daddy's Thing.
Tobias Character Comedy Wordplay/Pun ★ Rewatch Callback All Jokes — 100 analyzed
Show all ↓ Hide ↑ TV Crew Member: Looks like we got ourselves an Anus Tart.
Tobias · Narrator: What Sudden Valley does to these cell phones!
Narrator: Yes, Tobias was finally about to get a starring role on a hit TV show. / It's John Beard's To Entrap a Local Predator Supercreeps.
Narrator Irony/Sarcasm Misdirection ★ Rewatch Narrator: It's Tobias' Arrested Development.
Narrator Meta/Self-Referential Wordplay/Pun ★ Rewatch Tobias · Lindsay: I'm sorry. Everyone thinks I'm gay? / Well, I mean, it's kind of a running joke in the family.
Tobias: ♪ It's just a fallacy! ♪ / 'Misleading?'
Tobias Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm ★ Rewatch George Sr. · Tobias: Well, you look like I feel. / Gay? / No, I... No.
Narrator · Tobias: They're still reading it, but... Well, I guess I can leave them some Love. So he just took Eat and Pray.
Narrator: Eat was easy, although it provided no cosmic answers for him.
Narrator Deadpan/Understatement Absurdist Callback Tobias: And these romantic gestures are possibly why people think I'm a homosexual.
Tobias Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm Callback Tobias · Lindsay: A new start. Filled with compassion and love. / I like that. / Well, I've already got the license plate, so go cry in your pie!
Narrator · Indian Drivers: I guess this is why you never see them driving convertibles. / Stay in your lane, anus tart! / Anus tart!
Tobias: Well, there we go. India clean.
Tobias Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement Tobias: I look like one of those hot guys from Spartacus.
Tobias Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm Tobias · Canadian Passenger: Canadian? / No, I'm American. / Yeah. I'm Canadian. / Sorry.
Tobias: How could they not have Failure to Launch?
Tobias Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm ★ Rewatch Narrator · Doctor: Tobias experienced India from the inside of a hospital room... once outside the airport and once in the elevator when his sheet got caught and he was pulled off his gurney. Literally. Two places indeed.
Indian Doctor · Tobias: It's like that new show we just got, Laugh-In. / My name is... Oh! Now I've broken my skull in a third place! On this elephant guy statue!
Doctor · Tobias · Narrator: You should be a comedy actor. / And finally it had. / This is the sign I've been... Looking for.
Tobias · Narrator: Although, as we discovered when our MasterCard bill came back, it was the same one she took.
Tobias: For 2,000 rupees, we'd both go down on Matthew McConaughey.
Tobias Character Comedy Dark/Subversive ★ Rewatch Narrator · Michael · Lucille: At the time of this family meeting, 2,000 rupees was $36. / I wouldn't. / Of course you wouldn't, Michael. You never accept help from anyone.
Tobias · Real Estate Agent: Listen, I'm an actor, you're an agent. You do the math. / In other words, you do the math. The money, the negotiating. / You know I'm not that kind of agent, right? I'm a real estate agent. I'm a predator.
Tobias · Real Estate Agent: All you need to do is tell people what a terrific actor I am, 'cause I can't do it believably. / Sounds like it shouldn't be too much work.
Tobias: Okay, here's the number of my current agent Mike Matthews. He's at Allstate. Fire him.
Tobias Character Comedy Absurdist ★ Rewatch Tobias: Hi. I'm after pending. / Taft-Hartley pending.
Tobias Character Comedy Visual Gag ★ Rewatch Tobias · Lindsay: Including duck l'orange! / Lindsay! Lindsay, get the scooper! / Throw oranges at it. / Hot orange! Hot orange! / It's throwing its voice! Lindsay!
Narrator: And so they went to the Fountain Valley China Garden instead.
Narrator Deadpan/Understatement Setup/Punchline Narrator: The suicide of his ruined and despondent agent certainly could [deter Tobias].
Narrator Dark/Subversive Deadpan/Understatement Tobias · Narrator: I believe he died as a warning, in a way, his message perhaps to live within our means and be realistic about our lives. / And yet it didn't. / Well, then I shall redouble my efforts so that he died in vain. / Meaning he will have led a pointless life, is what I mean.
Tobias: Meaning he will have led a pointless life, is what I mean. Yes, carry on. Thank you.
Tobias Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement Callback Lindsay · Tobias: What did you say the name of this acting class was again? / Method One Clinic. / Okay, I'm gonna go get coffee. / Garden Grove Method One Clinic.
DeBrie: And I made it in that movie, the Fantastic Four, but it wasn't fantastic for me. / I got carried away. / And I'm like, 'This is up, and I've got to get my together or I'm gonna be too.'
DeBrie Character Comedy Absurdist ★ Rewatch Tobias · DeBrie: Okay, notes. First of all, it seemed you were slurring a bit there, and I just think you'd have so much more fun punching those words. / 'This is up, sir.' / I'm sorry. I'm not familiar with the piece, so...
Narrator: Twenty years earlier, DeBrie Bardeaux had played Sue Storm in the low-budget version of the Fantastic Four, produced by Imagine Entertainment, when, during Imagine's Christmas party, a drunk lawyer reminded them they'd lose the rights if they didn't make the film in the next six days. After a two-hour search, they found their entire cast.
Narrator Absurdist Dark/Subversive ★ Rewatch Narrator: They also proved useful six days later at the wrap party.
Narrator Dark/Subversive Deadpan/Understatement ★ Rewatch DeBrie: I almost never get recognized as the Invisible Girl. / I can't believe you saw me.
DeBrie Wordplay/Pun Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Tobias · Narrator: Well, I thought it was 'fantastic.' / Actually, most of the performance that had so captivated Tobias... was performed by a fishing line.
Tobias · DeBrie · Bystander: Hey, maybe she came into this Light Bulbs Unlimited. / She was here a minute ago. / This is the gayest Starbucks ever! / Did his fishing line break, too?
DeBrie: Carl Weathers used to give us grape juice. But then he'd add $5 to our credit card.
DeBrie Callback Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Callback Tobias · DeBrie: Well, here is to our acting addiction. Yep. May we never be cured.
Tobias · DeBrie: DeBrie, are you crying? Oh, I'm crying. Oh, it's a nosebleed.
Narrator: And after a not-very-cute meet-cute, Tobias continued to find DeBrie's behavior delightful, even when the methadone made her think she was a piece of toast.
Narrator Absurdist Deadpan/Understatement ★ Rewatch Tobias: Now I can see a pretty face under all that butter substitute.
Tobias Character Comedy Absurdist Callback Narrator: She had been in a series of soft-core porn movies about women leading straight men into gay sex called StraightBait.
Narrator Setup/Punchline Dark/Subversive ★ Rewatch DeBrie (in StraightBait) · Male Characters (in StraightBait): If you want to have sex with me, then you've got to have sex with him first. / And if you don't want to have sex with her, you must be gay. / I'll show you how not gay I am.
Narrator: She did six of these movies, and after lunch, did three more.
Narrator Deadpan/Understatement Dark/Subversive ★ Rewatch DeBrie: Marky Bark, sometimes he doesn't know when I'm in the same room. / And sometimes it feels like it's not the face blindness, you know?
DeBrie Character Comedy Dark/Subversive ★ Rewatch Tobias: I've yet to make more money as an actor than I ever did as a doctor. And that's with CountryWide behind me.
Tobias Irony/Sarcasm Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Callback DeBrie · Tobias: You're a doctor, and you're out of work. / Well... / You can write scripts? / Well, I like to think so. / You should never give up a dream if you can write scripts.
Tobias · DeBrie: Well, I like to think so. You should never give up a dream if you can write scripts. You seem like you'd be a good doctor-actor.
DeBrie · Narrator: You remind me of Billy Crystal... / It would have broken Tobias' heart if he'd known she was about to say 'Billy Crystal Meth,' a funny drug dealer.
DeBrie · Narrator: You remind me of Billy Crystal... / Once again, she was going to say, 'Billy Crystal Meth.'
Tobias · DeBrie: Did you see my license plate, 'A-N-U-S-T-A-R-T'? / Did you see my StraightBait movie of the same name?
Narrator / Score: ♪ Coincidence ♪
Tobias · DeBrie: Can I just improv my way out of a marriage? / Yes, and let's do this. / Blackout.
Narrator · DeBrie · Tobias: If you're wondering what 'too' referred to, it was this... / Let's do this. / Blackout. / And scene, as they say. / Her heart stopped! She's dying!
Medical Staff · Tobias · Doctor: Someone say 'butter' out here? / Oh, my God, that's a butter face. / How much butter did the patient have? / I don't know. A Star Trek chess set's worth.
Doctor · Paramedic · Tobias: Damn it, that Swappigan's puts more people in this hospital... / We got a 61-year-old male in full cardiac arrest coming through. / Be careful of her face! She's an actress!
Doctor · Tobias: How much butter did the patient have? I don't know. A Star Trek chess set's worth.
Tobias: We're both actors!
Tobias Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm Doctor · Tobias: I'm afraid that you have tested positive for chlamydia, syphilis, gonorrhea, hepatitis, pancreatitis, trichomonitis, non-gonococcal urethritis. All the itises, really, and there's also a host of osises. / Now, what this means in non-medical terms is that you have landed a real party girl.
Tobias · DeBrie · Doctor: You didn't tell me you had a drug problem. / We met at a methadone clinic. / Are you high? We met at an acting class. / The Method One... / There it is. I'm gonna let you guys hash this out.
Tobias: DeBrie, look, some people struggle with addiction. Other people are incapable of ever being nude. Everybody has something.
Tobias Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm ★ Rewatch Callback Tobias · DeBrie: When I first saw StraightBait, there were two men making love, but I couldn't take my eyes off of you. / You watched StraightBait? / Oh, just two, four and nine.
DeBrie · Tobias: You watched StraightBait? Oh, just two, four and nine.
DeBrie Tobias Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement ★ Rewatch Callback Tobias · Bystanders: Come one, come all! Get your photo taken with Sue Storm from the Fantastic Four! / Hey, is that Jessica Alba? / No, this is the original Sue Storm, DeBrie Bardeaux! / Who?
DeBrie · Tobias: I do have a law degree. / I know, I know, and I'm a doctor. But no, let's not settle.
Tobias · Bystander: They're the Ambiguously Gay Duo. / I assure you, there's nothing ambiguous about me. I'm Johnny Storm, the Human Flamer.
Tobias: And this is Sue Storm, my sister and fellow fighter-in-law.
Tobias Wordplay/Pun Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Tobias · Narrator: Mr. Feinberg? Would it change your mind if I offered you a free Sue Storm armband? / It did not change his mind.
Narrator: And although the hate crime charges were dismissed, they were told they could not continue to pose as the Fantastic Four.
Narrator Deadpan/Understatement Dark/Subversive ★ Rewatch DeBrie · Tobias: Can they really make us leave Hollywood Boulevard? / Well, apparently in this instance, paper beats rock. / You have a rock? / No, I am your rock now.
Tobias: Ability to Be Invisible Person. / Actually, technically, I'm Rock Monster, and this is Ability to Be Invisible Person.
Tobias Absurdist Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Police Officer: What brings you to at least 500 feet past the entrance of Disneyland?
Child · Tobias · Police Officer: They're the Fantastic Four. / Actually, technically, I'm Rock Monster... / We're The Thing and the Invisible Girl. / You're under arrest.
Tobias · Police Officer: We're not gonna kill him, we're just gonna handcuff him. You can't shoot us 'cause it's not a felony.
Police Officer 1 · Police Officer 2: If it happens again, you know, it will be a third strike. / Three-strikes law's up for review in the appellate courts, but we really shouldn't be charging.
DeBrie · Tobias: We're broke. / But you can't sell your Fantastic Four costume. I mean, that would be like a fisherman selling his fishing costume.
DeBrie · Tobias: No, I was gonna have sex with him. / For money. / What? No. Put that back on.
DeBrie · Tobias: Hey, I'm not a thing. / Hey, I am a thing.
Tobias · George Michael: Michael. / No, George Michael. / Somebody, help!
Narrator · Bird/Maeby: And that's when he heard what sounded like two ostriches making love to a pop hit. / But was actually this. / ♪ Why don't you go away, go away / Get away, get away, stay away / You're hopelessly hopeless ♪
Lucille 2: You know, the doctor said if that bird had gotten through my second layer of makeup, it could've done permanent damage to my skin.
Lucille 2 · Tobias: How would you like to come work for me at Austerity? / The rehab center? That's yours? / Well, my brother Argyle runs it day-to-day.
Lucille 2 · Narrator · Tobias: It would only pay 120 grand a year to start. / Tobias, whose girlfriend had nearly sold her body for money in front of him, knew that everyone at some time had to face reality. / Ummmmmm... / But this wasn't the time. No.
DeBrie · Tobias: You turned it down? Mmm-hmm. / I almost a guy for a hamburger, and you turned down $120,000 a year?
Tobias · DeBrie: After all, a doctor in India told me that I have the gift to make people laugh. / Why are you crying? / You're worse than Marky. He couldn't see me, but you can't hear me.
Tobias DeBrie Character Comedy Dark/Subversive ★ Rewatch Callback DeBrie: You're worse than Marky. He couldn't see me, but you can't hear me.
DeBrie Character Comedy Dark/Subversive ★ Rewatch Callback Process Server · Tobias: Who are you supposed to be? / I'm The Thing from Fantastic Four. / You've been served.
Process Server · Tobias: Who are you supposed to be? I'm The Thing from Fantastic Four. You've been served.
Tobias · CIA Agent: Are you undercover as well? / I'm CIA. Not here for you, though. / Scoping out Imagine Entertainment.
Tobias: Daddy needs to get his rocks off.
Tobias Character Comedy Wordplay/Pun ★ Rewatch Narrator / John Beard: On the next To Entrap a Local Predator... / Predator gets its first rock-solid case.
Tobias: I'm here to see my little girl. / I wanted to show her Daddy's Thing.
Tobias Character Comedy Wordplay/Pun ★ Rewatch Callback John Beard · Tobias: How old is she? / I want to say 19? / But I like to think of her as 15.
John Beard (offscreen) · Narrator · Tobias: Well, you're free to go. She's not here. / But this creep won't take 'go' for an answer. / That's all right. I'll stay, I'll wait.
TV Crew · TV Producer · Tobias: Tell him there's a raccoon in the backyard. / Hey, guess what? There's a raccoon out on the patio! / Where is that little guy?
John Beard / Producer · Crew Member · Tobias: Tell him there's a raccoon in the backyard. / Hey, guess what? There's a raccoon out on the patio! / Where is that little guy?
John Beard (voiceover) · Tobias: And this guy turns out to be a real comedian. / I just broke my skull in a fourth place. The patio!
Top Episodes — Arrested Development