Michael becomes convinced that an insurance salesman visiting the office is a part of the mafia, and Dwight and Andy accompany Michael to a meeting with him. Meanwhile, Kevin accidentally cancels Jim's credit card, while Jim and Pam are on their honeymoon in Puerto Rico.
WAR
83.5
Wins Above Replacement
“Mafia” ranks #67 of 183 The Office episodes on the Humor Index, scoring 89.5 — Elite. The episode packs 66 scored jokes at 2.8 per minute, averaging 7.3 on craft and 7.2 on impact, with Michael landing the most laughs. Every joke is ranked below with its individual craft and impact scores.
Get weekly comedy rankings
Join comedy fans getting new analyses, score drops, and the funniest moments each week. Free, no spam.
Top Jokes
Dwight: '"R" is among the most menacing of sounds. That's why they call it murder, not "mukduk."'
Dwight Absurdist Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Michael: 'And he also vaguely threatened me with testicular cancer.'
Michael Absurdist Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Dwight: Dwight's confessional: 'Jim's gone on his honeymoon. So I started borrowing his office to fart in. Then one day, I came in, and I just stayed. 'Cause this place is awesome.'
Dwight Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement ★ Rewatch Michael: 'If there is one thing I hate more than the mafia, it is a liar. I wish the mafia would go out and kill all the liars. And bury them in my yard. And I wouldn't tell the cops a thing.'
Michael Absurdist Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Andy: Andy's diagnosis: 'You got a leaky spark tube. So your car's totaled. You're just gonna want to get a refund on that.' / 'I work exclusively on motorcycles.'
Andy Character Comedy Absurdist ★ Rewatch Callback Standout Moments
Dwight: Dwight's confessional: 'Jim's gone on his honeymoon. So I started borrowing his office to fart in. Then one day, I came in, and I just stayed. 'Cause this place is awesome.'
Dwight Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement ★ Rewatch Michael: 'And he also vaguely threatened me with testicular cancer.'
Michael Absurdist Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Dwight: '"R" is among the most menacing of sounds. That's why they call it murder, not "mukduk."'
Dwight Absurdist Character Comedy ★ Rewatch All Jokes — 66 analyzed
Show all ↓ Hide ↑ Michael: Michael underlines 'mental' in 'fundamental' and announces 'Mental is a part of the word. I have underlined it.'
Michael: 'Because you're mental if you don't have a good time. You have to enjoy it. The fun is in it.'
Michael Character Comedy Absurdist Callback Dwight: When asked for small talk topics, someone suggests 'Small things... Peas, ball bearings, dimes.'
Dwight Absurdist Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Michael · Meredith: Meredith's small talk response: 'I caught my son taking a dump on the upper part of the toilet. He calls it an upper-decker.'
Michael · Jim: 'What you don't know about business I could fill a book with.' / 'Then do it.' / 'What?' / 'Write a book.'
Michael: 'The Fundamentals of Business by Michael Scott. Over 1 billion sold. More than the Bible. I'm not surprised.'
Michael Character Comedy Absurdist Callback Dwight: 'It feels like home now. Even better than my home. My home sucks.'
Dwight Deadpan/Understatement Character Comedy Callback Andy · Dwight: Andy and Dwight in Jim's office discussing Grotti: 'And his southern Italian heritage raises some flags.'
Michael: Michael: 'There is no such thing as monsters.' (in response to 'Mobsters are [a threat]')
Michael Wordplay/Pun Character Comedy Andy · Dwight: 'He drives an SUV.' / 'I knew it.' / 'More trunk space. Or should I say corpse space?'
Michael · Andy · Dwight: Michael: 'Guys, I drive an SUV. Does that mean I'm in the mob?' / 'No, not that by itself.'
Dwight: Dwight lists mob fronts: 'Sometimes it's selling insurance. Sometimes it's waste management or sanitation.'
Dwight Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm Oscar: Oscar's confessional: 'Pam and Jim are on their honeymoon, so there's not the usual balance between sane and others.'
Oscar Observational Deadpan/Understatement Oscar: Oscar: 'Toby has mentally checked out since June. It's a very dangerous time. The coalition for reason is extremely weak.'
Oscar Deadpan/Understatement Character Comedy Toby: Toby's confessional reaction: 'Oscar says I checked out, huh?' — delivered with complete vacancy.
Toby Reaction Beat Deadpan/Understatement ★ Rewatch Callback Ryan: Ryan on the mafia: 'First of all, there's no such thing as the mafia. What you have are specific families.'
Ryan Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm Michael: Michael: 'Too many different words coming at me from too many different sentences.'
Michael Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement Dwight · Michael: 'Lock your door!' / 'I'm not gonna lock my door.'
Oscar · Pam · Jim: Oscar calling Jim and Pam on their honeymoon: 'I'm so sorry to be calling you on your honeymoon... It's Michael. He thinks he's being shaken down by the mob.'
Pam: Pam's response: 'Unless someone very close to us is in immediate physical danger, you should not be calling us.'
Pam Deadpan/Understatement Character Comedy Dwight: 'Cops can't do anything until a crime has been reported. Not only that, but if they find out you snitched, you get a dead horse's chopped-off head in your bed.'
Dwight Absurdist Character Comedy Dwight: 'Criminals are like raccoons. You give them a taste of cat food, pretty soon they'll be back for the whole cat.'
Dwight Absurdist Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Dwight: 'The only way to defeat a bully is to stand up to him. Trust me, I have bullied a lot of people.'
Dwight Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm Michael: Michael: 'I like this plan. I'd like to officially withdraw my plan.' / 'My plan is out. We do it the hard way.'
Michael Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm Andy: Andy arrives at the restaurant dressed as a mechanic with a tire iron: 'If I'm gonna back you up, I need a weapon without drawing suspicion. And I have to justify it somehow, so I'm a mechanic with a tire thing.'
Andy Character Comedy Absurdist ★ Rewatch Michael · Andy: 'Do you know how to use it?' / 'To change tires? No. But it's metal. I could hit somebody.'
Michael Andy Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement Callback Michael · Andy: Michael sees Andy's loafers under the mechanic costume: 'You're wearing loafers.' / 'Forget it!'
Dwight · Michael: At the restaurant, Dwight has a tire iron on the table. Michael: 'Take that thing off the table. Please.' / 'Then I can't use it.' / 'I'm just gonna hide it.'
Dwight: Dwight scoping out the restaurant bathroom: 'The bathroom checks out clean. Nothing behind the toilet except this roach motel.'
Dwight Character Comedy Absurdist Dwight: 'You'll never kill it that way. You want to separate the head from the thorax.'
Dwight Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement Callback Grotti: Grotti complains about the booth: 'What's this, one of them half-booths, can't decide what it is type of...' and immediately moves the whole party to a different table.
Grotti Character Comedy Cringe/Discomfort Kevin · Pam · Jim: Kevin calls Jim and Pam's credit card company pretending to be Jim, gives Jim's full home address and last four digits of his social security number.
Jim: Jim to the credit card fraud department: 'I think that we should let the criminal use the card a little longer.'
Jim Deadpan/Understatement Irony/Sarcasm Callback Grotti: Grotti's elaborate food order: linguini, red sauce on the side (or he sends it back), garlic bread toasted not burnt (or he sends it back).
Grotti Character Comedy Cringe/Discomfort Michael · Dwight: Michael orders 'the gabba-gool.' The waiter doesn't know what it is. Dwight insists: 'Bring him the gabba-gool!'
Oscar · Kevin: Oscar to Kevin: 'This constitutes identity fraud.' / Kevin: 'I wouldn't last in jail, Oscar. I'm not like you.' / Oscar: 'What's that supposed to mean?' / Kevin: 'You don't know about jail? You would love jail.' / Oscar: 'Why would I love jail?' / Kevin: 'Because... you would love it.'
Oscar Kevin Cringe/Discomfort Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Andy · Stranger: A stranger approaches Andy (in mechanic costume) asking him to jump-start her car because her battery's dead and she has her kid with her.
Andy · Dwight · Stranger: Andy attempting to jump-start the car with no idea what he's doing. Dwight watching: 'He seems bad at this.' / Stranger: 'You want to do this, Junior?' / Dwight: 'I didn't think so.'
Andy: Andy's diagnosis: 'You got a leaky spark tube. So your car's totaled. You're just gonna want to get a refund on that.' / 'I work exclusively on motorcycles.'
Andy Character Comedy Absurdist ★ Rewatch Callback Michael: Michael's confessional about the Italian car: 'I had this Italian car. And it kept telling me how much it needed oil. But I wouldn't give it any oil. And then one day it exploded. And it killed everyone.'
Grotti · Michael: Grotti: 'Aren't you a mechanic? Why wouldn't you put oil in the car?' / Michael: 'It was before my technical training.'
Grotti: Grotti: 'These guys gonna take care of your things if you die tomorrow?'
Grotti Cringe/Discomfort Irony/Sarcasm Michael · Dwight: Michael buys the insurance. Dwight: 'You were man enough to back down. I'm proud of you.' / Michael: 'I had to make a snap decision.' / 'It wasn't snap. You were sitting there for an hour.' / 'It was a lot of snap decisions.'
Dwight · Michael: 'Do you know what snap decision means?' / 'It means like this.' [Michael snaps fingers]
Michael · Jim: Michael calls Jim on his honeymoon: 'I had to tell the hotel it was a medical emergency. I chose massive coronary, 'cause you told me that your dad had a bad heart.'
Michael Jim Character Comedy Cringe/Discomfort ★ Rewatch Jim · Michael: Jim on a catamaran giving advice that cuts out entirely: 'I'm gonna help you through it. All you're gonna need to... and then go to... and you'll be saved.'
Jim: Jim: 'Bermuda Triangle. Please don't call again.'
Jim Deadpan/Understatement Character Comedy Oscar: Oscar: 'Accounting-wise, no. But phone-wise, just call up and cancel it.'
Oscar Deadpan/Understatement Character Comedy Callback Michael: Michael: 'What about this cash for clunkers thing?'
Dwight · Andy: Dwight to Andy: 'We have let Michael down. And it's 85% your fault.' / Andy: 'He's alive, so you're welcome.'
Andy · Dwight: Andy suggests convincing Michael the guy isn't mafia. Dwight: 'That seems a little far-fetched.' Andy: 'More far-fetched than a mobster walking into a paper company for a low-level shakedown? And that happened.'
Andy · Dwight: Andy and Dwight presenting fake evidence that Grotti is clean: 'Nothing sticks to him. You still don't understand how it works.' / 'Turns out he's a totally lovely guy. Sweetest guy on the force, really. Class act. Boy scout.'
Michael: 'If there is one thing I hate more than the mafia, it is a liar. I wish the mafia would go out and kill all the liars. And bury them in my yard. And I wouldn't tell the cops a thing.'
Michael Absurdist Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Michael: 'Not that I would be lying, per se. But I would just get really quiet all of a sudden.'
Michael Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement Callback Michael · Grotti: Michael calls Grotti back: 'I think you know exactly why... because you were trying to scare me into buying insurance... You suck!' / 'I won't buy your stupid insurance.' / 'The only person that actually needs insurance is you if you show your face around here again.'
Dwight · Michael: Dwight reveals they lied about Grotti being clean: 'Next time you look in the mirror, you're gonna be looking at a guy who stood down the mafia.' / Michael: 'What do you mean?' / Dwight: 'We just told you he wasn't mafia so you wouldn't be scared.'
Dwight · Andy: 'You successfully backed down the mob. You made the mafia apologize to you. You made the mafia be polite.'
Michael · Dwight · Andy: Michael's retelling of the phone call: 'So I looked him in the eye, and I said, "Not today, Grotti. Not today. And not tomorrow. And not the next day or the day after that. And you can tell all your friends that if I see them, then they are already dead." I said something like that.' / 'Very close.'
Oscar: Oscar confessional: 'Just to be clear, he backed down an insurance agent from Mutual of Harrisburg.'
Oscar Deadpan/Understatement Irony/Sarcasm ★ Rewatch Callback Michael · Dwight: Michael immediately sends Dwight for coffee with a list of absurd conditions mirroring Grotti's food order: 'Not from the kitchen. Stop and Shop. If it's not Stop and Shop, I send it back. Large. If it's a medium, I send it back. If it's an extra-large, I send it back. How do you return coffee? Go.'
Jim: Jim: 'Just to be clear, he backed down an insurance agent from Mutual of Harrisburg.' [talking head] — with a coffee cup
Jim Deadpan/Understatement Reaction Beat ★ Rewatch Callback Kevin · Pam: Kevin calling Pam and Jim on their honeymoon: Pam erupts about the canceled credit card, then: 'I'll let you go. Tell Jim that I said "Hi."' / Pam: 'I will. I will, Kevin. I will make that my top priority.'
Kevin Pam Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm ★ Rewatch Callback Kevin: Kevin's final confessional: 'They have no idea what happened.'
Kevin Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement Callback Top Episodes — The Office