Rumors spread that Dunder Mifflin is in financial trouble, so Michael tries to distract the office by having everyone play a murder mystery game called Belles, Bourbon, and Bullets. Meanwhile, Andy uses the game as a way to ask out Erin, but fears he may have asked out Erin's character, instead of Erin herself.
WAR
81.7
Wins Above Replacement
“Murder” ranks #115 of 183 The Office episodes on the Humor Index, scoring 86.6 — Elite. The episode packs 71 scored jokes at 3.3 per minute, averaging 7.2 on craft and 7.1 on impact, with Michael landing the most laughs. Every joke is ranked below with its individual craft and impact scores.
Get weekly comedy rankings
Join comedy fans getting new analyses, score drops, and the funniest moments each week. Free, no spam.
Top Jokes
Dwight: Dwight's deductive monologue: 'It's never the person you most suspect. It's also never the person you least suspect, since anyone with half a brain would suspect them the most. Therefore I know the killer to be Phyllis... the person I most medium suspect.'
Dwight Character Comedy Absurdist Setup/Punchline ★ Rewatch Jim: Jim announces to the gathered, anxious office: 'There has been another murder.' The office, now conditioned, immediately snaps into game mode.
Jim Callback Misdirection Running Gag ★ Rewatch Callback Dwight: Dwight fighting himself — attacking himself with a throat punch, blocking, grasping his own wrist, then escalating to a groin punch, elbow, nose strike
Dwight Physical/Slapstick Escalation Absurdist ★ Rewatch Dwight: Dwight offers everyone jobs at Schrute Farms 'as human scarecrows. It doesn't pay much and you can't unionize.'
Dwight Character Comedy Absurdist Kevin · Michael: Kevin refuses to attack Michael: 'No way. Last time, you pulled my pants down, and then you tried to choke me with my shoelace.' Michael: 'False. I did choke you with your shoelace.'
Kevin Michael Setup/Punchline Character Comedy Escalation ★ Rewatch Standout Moments
Dwight: Dwight fighting himself — attacking himself with a throat punch, blocking, grasping his own wrist, then escalating to a groin punch, elbow, nose strike
Dwight Physical/Slapstick Escalation Absurdist ★ Rewatch Dwight: Dwight's deductive monologue: 'It's never the person you most suspect. It's also never the person you least suspect, since anyone with half a brain would suspect them the most. Therefore I know the killer to be Phyllis... the person I most medium suspect.'
Dwight Character Comedy Absurdist Setup/Punchline ★ Rewatch Jim: Jim announces to the gathered, anxious office: 'There has been another murder.' The office, now conditioned, immediately snaps into game mode.
Jim Callback Misdirection Running Gag ★ Rewatch Callback All Jokes — 71 analyzed
Show all ↓ Hide ↑ Michael: Michael introduces a self-defense class with the framing: 'as we all know, the one thing that thousand-year-old martial arts do all the time is change.'
Michael: Michael's scenario: 'You are all members of the yakuza, and you happen to be visiting the lackawanna trolley museum, and you are attacked by triads. How can you hold them off until your clan arrives?'
Michael Absurdist Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Michael: Michael's self-defense advice: 'You cannot go wrong with a throat punch.'
Michael Deadpan/Understatement Character Comedy Kevin · Michael: Kevin refuses to attack Michael: 'No way. Last time, you pulled my pants down, and then you tried to choke me with my shoelace.' Michael: 'False. I did choke you with your shoelace.'
Kevin Michael Setup/Punchline Character Comedy Escalation ★ Rewatch Michael: Michael confirms that his most worthy opponent is himself, then immediately qualifies: 'That is correct, unless there happen to be measles present.'
Dwight: Dwight fights himself — attacking himself with a throat punch, blocking, grasping his own wrist, then the demonstration escalates into Dwight genuinely struggling against his own body.
Dwight Physical/Slapstick Escalation Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Jim · Pam: Jim's reaction beat: 'Oh my god, he's making you look like such a fool.' Pam: 'He really is, but not for long.'
Jim Pam Reaction Beat Irony/Sarcasm ★ Rewatch Dwight: The self-fight climaxes with both 'sides' of Dwight losing control: 'You let go! You let go! Oh, you're right, I can't hold on!'
Dwight Physical/Slapstick Escalation ★ Rewatch Callback Michael: Michael: 'The important thing to remember, Jim, is we always have what is called the element of surprise.' — delivered while the fight is ongoing and Michael himself has been watching the chaos he created.
Michael Deadpan/Understatement Character Comedy Michael: Michael's talking head: 'I did stand-up comedy once. I killed.'
Michael Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm Michael: Michael: 'I get like eight emails a day.' (as if this is an enormous quantity)
Michael Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement Erin · Michael: Erin mishears 'the Journal' as Michael's personal feelings journal: 'Your feelings journal? You told me to put it in the time capsule.'
Michael: Michael: 'Oh, the wall.' (in response to being told he means the Wall Street Journal online)
Michael Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement Jim · Oscar · Ryan: The article about Dunder Mifflin declaring bankruptcy cuts off mid-sentence and costs $1.99 to finish.
Dwight: Dwight offers everyone jobs at Schrute Farms 'as human scarecrows. It doesn't pay much and you can't unionize.'
Dwight Character Comedy Absurdist Michael: Michael ends a phone call with David Wallace with: 'I'll catch you on the flippity-flip.'
Michael Character Comedy Wordplay/Pun Michael · Erin: Michael emerges from the bathroom. Erin asks if he threw up. Michael: 'No, just poopin'. You know how I be.' Erin: 'But it smells like throw-up in here.' Michael: 'Crazy world, lotta smells.'
Michael Erin Cringe/Discomfort Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement ★ Rewatch Andy: Andy's talking head: 'I like Erin. There, I said it.'
Andy Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement Andy: Andy's talking head concludes: 'It is time for the nard-dog to take matters into his own paws.'
Andy Character Comedy Wordplay/Pun Jim · Michael: Jim tries to calm the office: 'Monkey see, monkey do.' Michael: 'Monkey pee all over you. That... rhymes.'
Oscar: Oscar is giving a dry, detailed coupon code update in a staff meeting about the letter O vs. zero confusion — while the office is in potential financial collapse.
Oscar Irony/Sarcasm Observational Cringe/Discomfort Dwight: During the coupon meeting: 'He needs me. Seat-save infinity.'
Dwight Character Comedy Reaction Beat Michael: Michael's talking head: '"Battleship" got me through my parents' divorce. "Operation" got me through my vasectomy, i.e., my operation.'
Michael Character Comedy Setup/Punchline Wordplay/Pun Michael: Michael: 'I don't think I would have been able to endure my break-up with Holly had it not been for Toss Across.'
Michael Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement ★ Rewatch Michael: Jim pushes back on the game idea; Michael responds: 'This is my call, Jim. Big picture stuff. It's about murder.'
Michael Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm Jim: Jim's talking head explains 'Tube City': Michael's plan to run plastic tubes all over the office and place hamsters inside of them.
Jim Character Comedy Absurdist ★ Rewatch Michael: Michael assigns characters for the game. To the character who talks slowly in real life: 'Your character could, say, have been kicked in the head by a horse.'
Michael Dark/Subversive Character Comedy Andy · Erin: Andy gets character card 'Nathaniel Nutmeg, the local bartender and... Nellie's brother.' — reacting with dawning horror to the sibling relationship with his potential love interest's character.
Andy Erin Setup/Punchline Cringe/Discomfort ★ Rewatch Kevin: Kevin is assigned 'Voodoo Mama Juju, the witch doctor of the Savannah swamps': 'I'm not comfortable with this.'
Kevin Character Comedy Reaction Beat Michael: Michael complains about his character 'Caleb Crawdad, handsome playboy': 'Every night, a different woman, being oogled, having to hug and kiss and spoon. Oh! I make them feel beautiful.'
Michael Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm ★ Rewatch Jim · Michael: Jim checks his BlackBerry in character; Michael: 'It's my BlackBerry, Michael. I'm trying to get updates on the company.' Michael: 'Who's Michael? I'm Caleb Crawdad, I do declare.'
Jim · Michael: Jim: 'You don't have to keep saying, I do declare. Anytime you say something it means you're declaring.' Michael: 'That is the way southern people talk.' Jim: 'And what designing woman are you basing that on?' Michael: 'Delta Burke, I do declare.'
Jim Michael Setup/Punchline Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm ★ Rewatch Pam: Pam introduces herself as 'Deborah Utante' and someone remarks: 'That's clever. Debutante.'
Pam Wordplay/Pun Observational Michael: Michael describes the Savannah accent as 'more like molasses, just sort of spillin' out of your mouth.'
Michael Character Comedy Observational Oscar · Michael · Kevin: Oscar: 'Now do the Swedish Chef.' Michael: 'Uh, I'm not familiar. What province is he from?' Kevin: 'He lives on Sesame Street, dumbass.'
Dwight: The butler (Dwight or another) goes full class-warfare on the accusation: 'You rich people! You think you can do whatever you want to the servant class!'
Dwight Character Comedy Escalation Dwight: Dwight (as butler): 'I will poison your food.'
Dwight Deadpan/Understatement Dark/Subversive Character Comedy Andy · Michael: Andy (as Nathaniel) arrives late, is told 'Sir, there has been a murder and you are a suspect.' Andy: 'Okay. Hang on just a second. Let me settle in and I'll be right back.'
Michael: Michael: 'I do believe that the game is a big hit. People are really divin' into their characters. Y'all...' [long pause] 'I made a mistake.'
Michael Reaction Beat Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Andy · Erin: Andy (as Nathaniel) asks 'Nellie' (Erin) out on a date within the game — she accepts in character — both grinning.
Andy Erin Cringe/Discomfort Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Kevin: Kevin (as Voodoo Mama Juju) explains his dark arts: 'It's not my fault. I was exposed to Harry Potter.'
Kevin Character Comedy Absurdist ★ Rewatch Dwight · Phyllis: Dwight (mid-accusation) pivots to ask Phyllis out: 'Do you want to go out on a date with me? We can make out by the horses.'
Dwight · Phyllis: Phyllis (as Nellie): 'Well, you know old Nellie is always up for a romp in the hay.' Dwight: 'How 'bout a threesome?' Phyllis: 'My boudoir's always open.' Dwight: 'Nice.'
Dwight Phyllis Cringe/Discomfort Character Comedy Escalation ★ Rewatch Callback Andy: Andy's talking head: 'I'm a little worried I might have asked out Naughty Nellie and not Erin, which would be a whole lot less appealing, because Naughty Nellie says yes to everyone, and she might be a murderer.'
Andy Character Comedy Cringe/Discomfort Callback Oscar · Michael: Oscar tries to deliver real news about stopped vendor payments; Michael refuses to engage until Oscar delivers it in character with a Southern accent.
Oscar Michael Character Comedy Cringe/Discomfort Running Gag ★ Rewatch Oscar: Oscar (in forced Southern accent): 'This here plantation, we're runnin' low on, uh, greenbacks, and we're havin' problems payin' the people who give us the seeds and the dirt. We can't pay 'em.'
Oscar Character Comedy Cringe/Discomfort Absurdist Callback Michael: Michael insists the narrator's reveal is 'a misdirection': 'We still don't know who the murderer is.'
Michael Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm Running Gag Michael: Jim trying to restore order while Michael wanders calling: 'Nellie Nutmeg, come back in heyah! I can't do this mahself. Voodoo Mama Juju! What am I gonna do?'
Michael Character Comedy Physical/Slapstick Kevin · Jim · Andy · Erin: Kevin: 'I was just thinking about Weekend at Bernie's. So funny. The guy's dead the whole time.' Jim: 'I haven't seen it.' Kevin: 'Speaking of weekends — you excited about our date this weekend?'
Andy · Erin: Andy (as Nathaniel) offers Erin (as Nellie) a date at 'The finest steakhouse in all Savannah.' Erin: 'Savannah? That's a far way from Scranton.'
Andy Erin Cringe/Discomfort Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Andy · Erin: Andy and Erin simultaneously deny the date was real. Andy: 'Did you mean a real date?' Erin: 'No.' Andy: 'Totally not.' — both clearly disappointed.
Andy Erin Cringe/Discomfort Awkward Silence ★ Rewatch Callback Andy: Andy's talking head: 'I thought it was for real... so I was excited, but it was just — it was part of the game.'
Andy Cringe/Discomfort Character Comedy Callback Michael · Dwight: Michael (as Caleb Crawdad) is interrogating Dwight (as himself) about an attack with water. Dwight: 'I already declared you it was too dark to tell!' Michael: 'Stop playing games with me, Crawdad! This is not a game! This is my life!'
Michael Dwight Meta/Self-Referential Irony/Sarcasm Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Jim · Pam: Pam and Jim's private conversation about the bankruptcy: Jim: 'I'm trying to think of a way this all ends up fine, and I can't think of one.'
Jim Pam Deadpan/Understatement Dark/Subversive Michael · Pam: Michael sees Pam stressed and says 'Deb, what in the world? Do you have the vapors?' — immediately trying to pull her back into the game.
Michael · Dwight: Michael is lying on the floor as a dead body with 'brain chunks' around him. 'I'm the dead body and these are my brain chunks.' Dwight: 'Hey, shut up. You're dead.'
Michael Dwight Physical/Slapstick Character Comedy Visual Gag ★ Rewatch Michael · Jim: Jim tries to pull Michael aside to talk seriously. Michael: 'They need this game, Jim. Let us have this stupid little game, all right?'
Michael · Erin: Erin startles Michael, who dramatically clutches his chest: 'You startled me! My stars, my heart nearly leapt out of my chest.'
Michael · Erin: Erin tells Michael it's David Wallace on the phone. Michael (as Caleb): 'Tell him I'm not heyah.' Erin: 'You're not gonna answer the phone?' Michael: 'No, I only answer to Detective Wallace, 'cause I got a warm body in the other room.'
Michael Erin Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm Running Gag ★ Rewatch Jim · Pam · Office: Jim reports back on Wallace's call: 'What's the news?' Jim (beat): 'Nothing yet.' — but we saw the call where Wallace said the company is insolvent.
Jim: After receiving devastating news from David Wallace, Jim tells the office: 'Nothing yet.' Cut to Jim looking at camera.
Jim Reaction Beat Irony/Sarcasm ★ Rewatch Jim: Jim's talking head: 'I think today was a good day to have two managers, because if you're a family stuck on a lifeboat in the middle of the ocean, one parent might want to just keep rowing. But if the other parent wants to play a game, it's not because they're crazy. It's because they're doing it for the kids. And I get that now.'
Jim Character Comedy Observational ★ Rewatch Kevin: Kevin's talking head: 'My little heart can barely take it no more.' — completely in character as his Southern game persona, about the murders.
Kevin Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement Oscar: Oscar's talking head: 'Today is the hardest I have worked in a long, long time.'
Oscar Irony/Sarcasm Deadpan/Understatement Michael · Dwight · Office: The final game standoff: Michael calls for everyone to put down their guns. Dwight: 'I have crossbows.' Michael: 'We'll put down our weaponry on the count of three.' Count reaches 'two' — long pause — then 'three' — another pause — 'three.'
Jim: Narrator: 'Andy revealed himself to be a double agent, at which point Dwight felt comfortable revealing he also was a double agent, and then Michael announced to everybody that, get this, he was a double agent. Oh, and it is 6:00.'
Jim Deadpan/Understatement Escalation Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Jim: 'Oh, and it is 6:00.' [End of workday; everyone's still in character and doesn't care]
Jim Deadpan/Understatement Irony/Sarcasm Office: The episode ends with the office still in-character chaos: 'It wasn't me! I'm not goin' down for this! Hey, I want to go home. Get the keys out of my purse, start the car.'
Office Character Comedy Escalation Top Episodes — The Office