Just as Michael's relationship with Sally starts to flourish, Maggie Lizer returns nine months pregnant, and Michael immediately assumes he's the father. George Michael attempts to break up with Ann, and Buster learns he's being deployed to Iraq.
Buster's amputation crisis spawns 40 jokes in 22 minutes—character chaos at peak density.
Directed by Danny Leiner · Written by Jim Vallely, Chuck Martin
WAR
142.4
Wins Above Replacement
“Out On A Limb” ranks #27 of 84 Arrested Development episodes on the Humor Index, scoring 96.4 — Elite. The episode packs 89 scored jokes at 3.0 per minute, averaging 7.7 on craft and 7.5 on impact, with Michael landing the most laughs. Every joke is ranked below with its individual craft and impact scores.
Get weekly comedy rankings
Join comedy fans getting new analyses, score drops, and the funniest moments each week. Free, no spam.
Top Jokes
Narrator · Buster: [On the Next] 'Loose seal! Watch out for loose seal!' / 'I don't care about Lucille! She lies!' / Narrator: 'And then a seal bites off his hand.'
Maggie: Maggie: 'To tell you the truth, I am so relieved not to be pretending to be blind anymore. It's actually taught me not to rely on cheap tricks to get the jury's sympathy.'
Maggie Irony/Sarcasm Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Lucille: Lucille's takedown of Tobias: 'You are a worse psychiatrist than you are a son-in-law, and you will never get work as an actor because you have no talent.'
Lucille Character Comedy Dark/Subversive Gob: Gob: 'Well, she's got a name. And I'm gonna find out what it is, and then I'm gonna make a pun on it, and that's what I'll call her. Bad example — if her name's Amy, I'll call her Blamy.'
Gob Character Comedy Absurdist Tobias: Tobias's response to Lucille's devastating takedown: 'Well, if she's not going to say anything, I certainly can't help her.'
Tobias Deadpan/Understatement Character Comedy All Jokes — 89 analyzed
Show all ↓ Hide ↑ Narrator: The narrator warns against ordering the Skip's Scramble immediately after describing it as famous and containing everything on the menu.
Narrator Deadpan/Understatement Misdirection ★ Rewatch Narrator · Michael: Narrator reveals that their eight dates included 'a record-tying three lovemaking sessions in one night for Michael,' punctuated by Michael's offscreen 'Yes!'
Sally · Michael · George Michael: Sally suggests they'd have had 'an entirely different kind of child' if they'd gotten together in high school, while Michael's actual son George Michael is shown nearby.
George Michael · Maeby: George Michael is nervous about being 'on his third Virgin Mary,' not realizing there's no alcohol in it.
Michael: Michael's awkward aside 'She's a shot-putter. And I'm dating her.' after the kids leave the table.
Michael Deadpan/Understatement Character Comedy Michael · George Michael: Michael asks 'Who?' about Ann, then backtracks: 'I meant, uh, her.' — the running 'Ann? Her?' gag.
Ann · George Michael: Ann confronts George Michael about skipping church to do 'neither' (not church, not working), then is horrified he's drinking — which is a Virgin Mary.
George Michael · Ann · Waiter: The waiter delivers George Michael's virgin piña colada mid-Ann's religious scolding, making it look like he's 'drinking'
George Michael: George Michael on Ann: 'I mean, I guess we've lost some of the heat since we have kissed...I always assumed she would break up with me.'
George Michael: 'Well, she just killed my buzz.' — George Michael after Ann leaves
Lindsay: Lindsay responds to Michael's news about three lovemaking sessions: 'Oh, big deal, three times. I've had three times plenty of times.'
Lindsay Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm Callback Michael · Lindsay: 'Yes!' Michael's offscreen exclamation is followed by Lindsay asking 'Did you call my name?' / 'Absolutely not.'
Lindsay · Tobias: Lindsay says 'Oh, how delicious!' then 'Oh, hey, let's not spin in the comfy chair' then 'Look at this delicious piece of irony. I'm being sued for divorce.' — referring to Tobias being sued, not herself.
Lucille: Lucille: 'Look at this delicious piece of irony. I'm being sued for divorce.'
Lucille Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm Gob · Narrator: Gob: 'Yeah, I keep forgetting that I got married.' / Narrator: 'Gob met a woman one night. And after a series of escalating dares, married her.'
Narrator · Gob: Gob's wife is revealed to be 'a seal dealer' — she 'raised and sold seals to aquariums.'
Gob: Gob tried to include a seal in his magic act: 'There's a reason you don't typically see live seals in a magic show.'
Gob Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement ★ Rewatch Gob: A seal interrupts Gob's magic trick attempt, causing a cat to screech. Gob's casual redirect: 'Oh, look-it over... there.'
Gob Physical/Slapstick Character Comedy Gob · Michael: Gob can't remember his wife's name. 'Krindy.' 'Name's not Krindy, Gob.' 'Ah, Saul Zentsman. No, that's her lawyer.'
Gob: Gob: 'Well, she's got a name. And I'm gonna find out what it is, and then I'm gonna make a pun on it, and that's what I'll call her. Bad example — if her name's Amy, I'll call her Blamy.'
Gob Character Comedy Absurdist Michael · Lindsay: Michael suggests they take responsibility for their relationship failures. Lindsay: 'I think it's Mom's fault.' Michael: 'I was gonna say the exact same thing.'
Lucille · Lindsay: Lucille rolls in on the spinning chair (which Lindsay had complained about) and delivers: 'So this is how my children speak of me when I'm not here.'
Lucille: Lucille's response to Buster going to war: 'the answer is no, he's not going in the ocean.'
Lucille Character Comedy Absurdist ★ Rewatch Michael · Lucille: Michael: 'Like, say, signing him up for the army during wartime.' Lucille: 'What the hell was I supposed to do? Michael Moore confronted me in front of the whole country.'
Michael · Lucille: Michael corrects Lucille: 'First of all, it wasn't Michael Moore. It was a look-alike. And it wasn't in front of the whole country. It was for a bit on Jimmy Kimmel Live.' Lucille: 'I don't know who that is, and I don't care to find out.'
Buster · Lucille: Lucille and Buster have hired a photographer for their beach meeting. 'We haven't done this since the Balboa Bay Window magazine.'
Buster · Lucille: Buster: 'I was 30 years old then, Mother. I'm 32 now!' — correcting Lucille's claim about his age while explaining why he's going to war.
Lucille · Narrator: Lucille: 'Well, I may not have been a perfect mother. But, you know, kids don't come with a handbook.' Narrator: 'In fact, there are thousands of books written on child-rearing. But Lucille was in denial.'
Barry: Barry: 'A waitress that works there is claiming that by eating Skip's Scramble several times a week is making her a fatty.' — Barry's current case introduced.
Barry Running Gag Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Callback Barry · Michael: Barry: 'Oh, well, I got Michael out of his marriage, didn't I?' Michael: 'Actually, she died.' Barry: 'You're kidding. I've been taking credit for that for years.' / 'Credit?'
Barry: Barry about opposing counsel: 'I have Chinese with him every Friday night at Miss Temple's.' Then: 'He's tough.'
Barry Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement Gob · Barry: Gob: 'I just want my wife back.' Barry: 'Save it for the stand, okay, Tom Jane?'
Gob Barry Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement Barry · Narrator: Barry: 'You know who's defending the fatty? Maggie Lizer.' — introducing Maggie as the opposing counsel in the fat suit case.
Narrator · Michael: Narrator explains Maggie was 'both pretending to be blind and prosecuting the family' during her affair with Michael. 'It was with her he'd first set the three-time record. Yes!'
Barry: Barry: 'Tell you the truth, I preferred it when she was blind.' — said about opposing counsel Maggie Lizer.
Barry Dark/Subversive Character Comedy Barry: Maggie's client (the 'fatty') wins over the jury by being visibly sympathetic. Barry: 'Oh, I'm cooked. They love her.'
Barry Irony/Sarcasm Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Maggie: Maggie: 'To tell you the truth, I am so relieved not to be pretending to be blind anymore. It's actually taught me not to rely on cheap tricks to get the jury's sympathy.'
Maggie Irony/Sarcasm Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Maggie · Juror Four: A juror has knitted something for Maggie during the trial. Maggie: 'Oh, Juror Number Four!' / 'I feel so bad I fought so hard to keep you off the jury.'
Narrator · Judge Ping: The judge has his bailiff assemble an 'Ocean-Sounds Toddler Rocker' as a gift for Maggie's baby — in chambers.
Michael: Michael to Maggie about the knitted item: 'Too bad the trial's not going longer. She could've knit you something that fit.'
Michael Setup/Punchline Dark/Subversive Michael · Maggie: Maggie says it's been 'about eight and a half months' since Michael saw her. Michael: 'Eight and a half months, huh? Wow. I see somebody has been counting the, uh—' [trails off in realization]
Narrator: Narrator: 'Michael had just learned that the woman he'd been intimate with eight and a half months earlier was eight-and-a-half months pregnant.'
Narrator Deadpan/Understatement Irony/Sarcasm Michael · Maggie: Michael: 'Didn't I use something?' Maggie: 'No.' Michael: 'You thought I was blind, remember?'
Michael · Maggie: Maggie: 'Don't worry. You're not the father, Michael.' / Michael exhales in relief / then immediately: 'No problem. Really? Right. You sure? I mean, uh— I could be. What if I was? Don't you want to discuss this maybe?'
Maggie: Maggie: 'If you're interested, come to the baptism. You can hurl a Bible at the baby.'
Maggie Dark/Subversive Deadpan/Understatement Michael · Sally: Michael explains to Sally that Maggie said it wasn't his baby — 'She said it wasn't mine, so—' Sally: 'Why are you telling me this?'
Lindsay: Lindsay summarizes Michael's love life: 'Are you insane? You broke up with her because somebody who doesn't want you might be pregnant with your baby?'
Lindsay Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement Michael: Michael says 'All I could see was her giant chest— box. She had this— Some people call it a chest. I call it a box.'
Michael Wordplay/Pun Character Comedy Gob · Lindsay: Gob's solution to the pregnancy mystery: 'Make 'em pee in a cup, and pee in a cup right in front of me.' / Lindsay: '...A pregnancy test.' Gob: 'Oh! [laughs] There's something we never had, huh, Lindsay?'
Tobias · Lindsay: Tobias: 'There's something we never had, huh, Lindsay? Oh, no.' — about a pregnancy test
Tobias · Maeby: Tobias: 'We had to create our little Frankenstein monster out of science and money and just a dash of—' [notices Maeby] 'Maeby, what— h-how long have you been standing there?'
Tobias: Tobias: 'Seems like only yesterday you were bursting forth from your mother's fertile womb.'
Tobias Character Comedy Cringe/Discomfort Lindsay · Tobias · Michael: Lindsay and Tobias agree to break into Maggie's house to collect a urine specimen. Lindsay: 'We will be like Tracy and Hepburn.' Tobias bursts in: 'What do you say, you old poop?' Michael: 'Oh, God, he's Hepburn.'
Lucille · Michael: Lucille declares 'I am done with Buster. He pushes my buttons.' Michael responds: 'He also zips you up and sands your elbows.'
Lucille · Michael: Lucille claims Buster is 'pretending he's going to war. Mr. Big Shot.' / Michael: 'Wait a minute. He said he's going to war? Aren't you worried?'
Lucille · Michael: Lucille: 'I need macaroons.' Michael: 'Oh, you're high!' / Lucille: 'Oh, well, you can win every argument like that, but that does not make you right.'
Lucille: Lucille shouts 'I don't want you telling him you're his father! I need ice!' in the same breath — apparent non-sequitur reveals Oscar may be Buster's father.
Lucille Misdirection Escalation ★ Rewatch Michael · Lucille: 'You're high!' / 'You're drunk!' — Michael and Lucille argue back and forth as the pipe grinds.
Tobias · Lucille: Tobias diagnoses Lucille with 'a psychological concept known as denial' — then Lucille: 'You are a worse psychiatrist than you are a son-in-law, and you will never get work as an actor because you have no talent.'
Lucille: Lucille's takedown of Tobias: 'You are a worse psychiatrist than you are a son-in-law, and you will never get work as an actor because you have no talent.'
Lucille Character Comedy Dark/Subversive Tobias: Tobias's response to Lucille's devastating takedown: 'Well, if she's not going to say anything, I certainly can't help her.'
Tobias Deadpan/Understatement Character Comedy Maeby · George Michael: Maeby: 'I know how to get rid of Ann. You put her in a room with Gangy. She'll criticize her away.' George Michael: 'But what would Gangy have to criticize about Ann?'
George Sr. · Narrator: George Sr. is wearing the 'God costume' from the annual Living Classics Pageant — a recreation of Michelangelo's Creation of Adam where he plays God.
George Sr.: George Sr.: 'What if I never get a chance to reach out and touch that hand of his again?' — in God costume, referencing the Creation of Adam pose.
George Sr. · Michael: Michael catches George Sr. leaving the attic to visit the Ford dealership; George Sr. defends it: 'Have you seen the new Ford Mustang? You could hump that hood.'
George Sr. · Michael: George Sr. claims he has 'never left the attic.' Michael: 'Two days ago. Right? Saw you floating around the Ford dealership.' George Sr.: 'Yeah, well, have you seen the new Ford Mustang? You could hump that hood.'
Maggie: Maggie is 'practicing with the pizza guy' — rehearsing how to answer the door for a pizza delivery to fool someone into thinking she's not home.
Maggie Absurdist Character Comedy Maggie: Maggie: 'She's taking the stand tomorrow. I want to make sure it creaks.' — about the fake-fat plaintiff
Maggie Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement ★ Rewatch Michael: Michael: 'There's so much I don't understand about the law.' — said while stalling Maggie so his family can break into her house.
Michael Irony/Sarcasm Deadpan/Understatement Lindsay · Tobias: Lindsay 'cloaks herself in Maggie's scent' using Maggie's perfume because 'she was blind when she bought this.'
Buster: Buster's response to the paternity reveal: 'You lied to me. Uncle Oscar's my father. He just told me so. And maybe you're not even my real mother. For all I know, Lucille 2 is my real mother.'
Buster Character Comedy Escalation ★ Rewatch Buster: Buster: 'Well, here's something you should know. I'm going to war!' — shouted triumphantly as an act of rebellion.
Buster Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm Tobias · Lindsay: Lindsay and Tobias in Maggie's shower: 'That's the first time we were in the shower since our honeymoon. And this time, no tears.'
Michael · Maggie: Michael about Sally: 'Yeah, I know. It's a funny name. But she's a doll.' Maggie: 'Yeah, I had one.' / 'If you pull her hair, she'd cry or something.' Michael: 'This one kinda does that too.'
Michael: Michael: 'If you pull her hair, she'd cry or something. This one kinda does that too.' — about Sally Sitwell
Michael Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement Lindsay: Lindsay on the phone from Maggie's house: 'Listen, you should know that that box that says 60 pounds — it's actually like two pounds. I think she's pregnant, Michael.'
Lindsay Irony/Sarcasm Misdirection ★ Rewatch Michael · Maggie: Michael to Maggie: 'So, no more lies. Tell me the truth. If that baby is mine, maybe we're meant to be together.' Maggie: 'Of course it is, Michael.'
Lindsay · Tobias: The Fünkes discover the fake pregnant belly/fat suit in the mystery box — a prosthetic stomach.
George Michael · Ann · Lucille: Lucille's attempt to have Ann criticized away by Lucille fails: Lucille is too distracted by Buster's departure to criticize. Ann: 'Hey, do you have any bread pudding? 'Cause you'd be surprised how much this one can put away.'
Ann · George Michael: Ann tells the grief-stricken Lucille: 'You know, when times are tough, you can always turn to the power of prayer.' George Michael: 'Here we go.'
Narrator: Narrator: 'This was a big get for God.' — on Ann converting the grief-stricken Lucille to prayer.
Narrator Deadpan/Understatement Irony/Sarcasm Lindsay · Michael: Lindsay's recorded message plays on Michael's phone: 'Hey, so what's the deal on Zuckerkorn? 'Cause you know my fat case — it's really pretty thin.' / 'Lying, untrustworthy—' 'Yeah.' 'Plus, I heard he hangs out at rest stops.'
Michael: Michael confronts Maggie with the fat suit: 'Which one are you wearing right now? Is this the ready-to-burst model?'
Michael Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm Michael · Narrator: Michael breaks up with Maggie: 'Good-bye. It's been fun—' [pause] '—not.'
Maggie: Maggie's riposte: 'Oh, you're so right, Michael. I really can't be trusted.' [pause] 'Cause I'm fakin' it—' [pause] '—not.'
Maggie Callback Irony/Sarcasm ★ Rewatch Callback Tobias: Tobias arrives to deliver the pregnancy confirmation: 'My wife and I finally had the thrill of seeing a plus sign on a pregnancy test. You're gonna be a daddy!'
Tobias Irony/Sarcasm Escalation ★ Rewatch Barry · Narrator: [On the Next] Barry: 'The fat girl in my Skip Church's case? Not fat. The attorney bought her a fat suit.' / 'I've got another case. Maggie is suing you for paternity.'
Lucille: [On the Next] Lucille prays: 'Take something else from us. Do whatever you have to to keep my boy from going to war.'
Lucille Dark/Subversive Irony/Sarcasm ★ Rewatch Narrator · Buster: [On the Next] 'Loose seal! Watch out for loose seal!' / 'I don't care about Lucille! She lies!' / Narrator: 'And then a seal bites off his hand.'
Top Episodes — Arrested Development