Pam and Jim work on their first sales pitch together to Donna, the manager of a local restaurant. But Michael keeps misreading the signals she's putting out. Meanwhile, Dwight encourages Kelly to try out for the minority training program.
WAR
81.4
Wins Above Replacement
“The Cover Up” ranks #116 of 183 The Office episodes on the Humor Index, scoring 86.6 — Elite. The episode packs 69 scored jokes at 2.9 per minute, averaging 7.3 on craft and 7.1 on impact, with Michael landing the most laughs. Every joke is ranked below with its individual craft and impact scores.
Get weekly comedy rankings
Join comedy fans getting new analyses, score drops, and the funniest moments each week. Free, no spam.
Top Jokes
Michael · Donna: Michael confronts Donna: 'Who is he?' Donna explains she's married. Michael: 'I'm the mistress?'
Michael · Donna: Michael confronts Donna about cheating. Donna: 'How do you know?' Michael: 'Pam told me.' Donna: (GASPS) 'Did she see me?' Michael: 'Nice effort.'
Darryl: Darryl's confessional: 'I don't have a plan exactly, more of a loose structure. Gives me freedom to improvise. It's like jazz.' (then scats '♪ Andy don't mess with me ♪')
Darryl Character Comedy Absurdist ★ Rewatch Andy · Stanley: Andy tells Stanley about a printer catching fire; Stanley responds: 'My doctor told me to cut out hotdogs. We all got problems.'
Andy Stanley Deadpan/Understatement Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Dwight · Donna: Dwight's gym pickup line: 'Hey, you know an exercise for two people that uses the whole body?' — Donna clearly expects a sexual answer — Dwight: 'Tractor pull.'
Standout Moments
Darryl: Darryl's confessional: 'I don't have a plan exactly, more of a loose structure. Gives me freedom to improvise. It's like jazz.' (then scats '♪ Andy don't mess with me ♪')
Darryl Character Comedy Absurdist ★ Rewatch Michael · Donna: Michael confronts Donna about cheating. Donna: 'How do you know?' Michael: 'Pam told me.' Donna: (GASPS) 'Did she see me?' Michael: 'Nice effort.'
Michael · Donna: Michael confronts Donna: 'Who is he?' Donna explains she's married. Michael: 'I'm the mistress?'
All Jokes — 69 analyzed
Show all ↓ Hide ↑ Jim: Jim's full sarcastic breakdown of the supposed Morse Code conspiracy — hiring a nanny, taking a class in 'a very outmoded and very unnecessary form of communication just so we can talk about you in front of you'
Jim Deadpan/Understatement Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Dwight: Dwight's foot-tapping rebuttal: 'I will when you lose the baby weight.'
Dwight Character Comedy Dark/Subversive Dwight: Dwight's confessional: 'Very well. I must have imagined it. I apologize.'
Dwight Deadpan/Understatement Reaction Beat ★ Rewatch Callback Michael · Dwight: Michael mistakes Jim clicking a pen for Dwight clicking a detonator — 'Jim, are you clicking a detonator?'
Jim · Dwight: After the detonator confrontation resolves, Jim sarcastically tells Dwight 'Fine. Tap away.' — Dwight clears his throat and presumably resumes tapping triumphantly
Jim Dwight Reaction Beat Character Comedy Callback Michael: Michael's talking head about Donna: 'Emotionally, and sexually, and orally.'
Michael Character Comedy Cringe/Discomfort Michael: 'She has a Pilates butt. But we need to find something to do this weekend beside have sex.'
Michael Character Comedy Cringe/Discomfort Stanley · Michael: Stanley gets up and says 'I have an idea for your weekend' — Michael enthusiastically encourages him — Stanley's idea is to go back to his desk
Office Staff: Suggestion: 'You and Donna should hit the Poconos. They have heart-shaped Jacuzzis, room enough for three.'
Michael · Office Staff: Michael went all the way to the Poconos to eat at P.F. Chang's — 'Why would you go all the way to the Poconos to P.F. Chang's when we have the Great Wall in Scranton?'
Michael: 'Because when your super-hot girlfriend says, "I want to go to Mount Pocono," you go to Mount Pocono, and you do her. And we screwed. Whoops! TMI!'
Michael Character Comedy Cringe/Discomfort Kelly: Kelly: 'Wait, that's crazy far. Are you sure she's not cheating?' — planting the episode's central conflict with zero tact
Kelly Character Comedy Misdirection Michael: Michael's comeback: 'You know what, Kelly, this is the real world. Not, The Real World, Scranton.'
Michael Wordplay/Pun Character Comedy Ryan · Kelly: Ryan corrects Kelly's 'some diner' reference: 'Some diner? It was the Starlight Diner. It's in a Life magazine spread about Americana.'
Ryan Kelly Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm ★ Rewatch Michael: As people try to reassure Michael, he adds 'And sex. We had sex, too.' completely unprompted
Michael Character Comedy Cringe/Discomfort Callback Michael · Office Staff: Michael: 'I said it on the second date.' — referring to 'I love you'; beat — 'That seems quick, even for lesbians.'
Ryan · Michael: Ryan's rapid-fire infidelity checklist: 'Does she keep her phone locked? Does she watch how much she drinks? Does she leave the room for calls? Does she keep perfume in her purse? Does she shower before sex? Does she shower after sex?' — and Michael says 'Yeah, she does all that.'
Michael · Pam: Michael: 'Run what?' Pam: 'Amok.' Michael: 'Why didn't you just say that, Pam?'
Michael: Michael: 'You have a bad imagination, it's stupid. I live in a fantasy world.'
Michael: Michael in confessional: 'It's the not knowing, that's what's killing me.' — delivered after knowing for about five minutes
Michael Character Comedy Irony/Sarcasm Michael · Dwight: Michael whispers to Dwight: 'I want someone to follow Donna. I want her tailed.' — then immediately negotiates his own PI's rate from $100 to $50 while saying 'Money's no object.'
Dwight: Dwight warns Michael as a PI: 'You might not like what I find. And you might not like how I find it.'
Dwight Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement Dwight: 'I'm just going to warn you, and I say this to all my clients, you might not like what I find. And you might not like how I find it.'
Dwight Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement Andy · Stanley: Andy tells Stanley about a printer catching fire; Stanley responds: 'My doctor told me to cut out hotdogs. We all got problems.'
Andy Stanley Deadpan/Understatement Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Gabe · Andy: Gabe's repeated interjections about almond butter/apricot preserves while Andy tries to escalate a safety crisis
Gabe Andy Character Comedy Cringe/Discomfort Jim · Pam: Jim's talking head: 'Wow, that dude is good.' / Pam: 'What do you mean?' / Jim: 'You didn't feel like he was hiding something? Like he was covering something up?'
Jim Pam Irony/Sarcasm Reaction Beat Darryl: Darryl's confessional: 'Two years ago Andy blamed the warehouse for a late shipment. Almost lost my job. I said, "Darryl, just wait. He's a fool. There's going to be an opportunity."'
Darryl Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement ★ Rewatch Dwight: Dwight's confessional about his investigation plan: 'All cases are solved with logic. The only logical way to find out if Donna is a cheater is to seduce her, bring her to orgasm, then call Michael and tell him the sad news.'
Dwight Character Comedy Absurdist ★ Rewatch Michael · Jim: Jim finds Michael eating mayonnaise and black olives: 'It's never too early for ice cream, Jim. But we didn't have any ice cream, so this is mayonnaise and black olives.'
Michael · Jim · Pam: Michael listing his great loves: 'Holly, Carole, Jan.' Then adds 'Helene.' Jim: 'Helene?' Michael: 'My mother.'
Jim: Jim's honest intervention: 'You kind of torpedo every romantic relationship you're in.'
Jim Irony/Sarcasm Character Comedy Dwight · Donna: Dwight and Donna awkwardly reach for the same gym weight simultaneously — 'Oh, gosh, we're both going for the same weight at the same time.'
Dwight · Donna: Dwight's gym pickup line: 'Hey, you know an exercise for two people that uses the whole body?' — Donna clearly expects a sexual answer — Dwight: 'Tractor pull.'
Dwight: Dwight: 'One thing you need to know about me, I don't quit until something tears or pops.'
Dwight Character Comedy Dark/Subversive Dwight · Donna: Dwight asks Donna if he can feel her pulse after a workout; she declines; he says 'Really?' with visible disappointment
Dwight · Donna: Dwight to Donna: 'We both know why I'm here.' Donna: (expecting something sensible) — Dwight: 'To see you naked while I'm naked.'
Dwight: Dwight to Donna as she leaves: 'Tomorrow's fertilizer, am I right?' — trying to bond over gym culture
Dwight Character Comedy Cringe/Discomfort Dwight · Michael: Dwight limps back: 'I pulled muscles in both my thighs. Thanks for asking.' — to which Michael immediately asks 'What happened with Donna?'
Michael · Dwight: Michael looks at Dwight's expense receipts: 'Who eats eight protein bars?' Dwight: 'People who don't trust egg whites.'
Dwight: Dwight reveals he told Donna and gym security that Michael sent him to check if she was cheating — 'Also, I joined the gym. You'll be billed monthly.'
Dwight Character Comedy Escalation Michael: Michael whispering to himself: 'I am not paying for that membership.'
Michael Reaction Beat Deadpan/Understatement Callback Michael · Jim: Michael moaning and grunting dramatically on the couch; Jim suggests he'd be more comfortable in his own office; Michael: 'No, I like the attention.'
Michael: Michael to Donna: 'You work at an adult arcade. You could have any man you want.'
Michael: Michael to Donna: 'Well, you are bonerific.'
Michael Character Comedy Cringe/Discomfort Michael · Donna: Michael asks Donna if they should go away. She asks what he'd say if she suggested it. Michael: 'Poop my pants.'
Michael · Donna: Michael: 'If I said we should go away for a couple days, you would...' [implies a romantic answer] / Michael: 'Poop my pants.'
Kevin · Andy: Kevin tells Andy that Gabe said 'Andy, problem, eliminate' — Andy: 'What? You don't know what it meant? How about, "Andy is a problem and we must eliminate him."' Kevin: 'Oh! I hadn't even thought of that.'
Kevin Andy Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement Dwight · Donna: Dwight interrogates Donna about where she bought her heart-shaped earrings — listing every possible mall store and then two malls by name
Dwight · Angela: Dwight's confessional deduction: 'Heart-shaped jewelry is not something a woman buys for herself. A man definitely bought it for her recently, and it wasn't Michael.' Pause. 'Wait, so you like heart-shaped jewelry, though, right? No. Except for the pendant that you bought me. Which I love.'
Creed: Creed appears in the background and goes 'Psst!' — then cut to his confessional where he explains he'd do the prank for free and has done 'a lot more for a lot less'
Creed Character Comedy Dark/Subversive Pam: Pam's confessional: She uses a Facebook mutual friend to look at Donna's photos — and instead of showing pictures of a boyfriend, she's looking at pictures of her own baby CeCe, narrating them with wonder
Pam Misdirection Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Pam · Jim · Michael: Pam pretends to want to discuss her sex life with Michael to distract him while Jim tries to get something signed — 'Yes, yes, I desperately want to speak with you about my sex life with Jim.'
Pam: Pam, desperate to get Michael alone: 'Yes, yes, I desperately want to speak with you about my sex life with Jim.'
Pam Cringe/Discomfort Character Comedy Michael: Michael randomly says: 'I gave my clubs away. Swear too much.' (about golf) — and he and Donna laugh
Andy · Gym Trainer: Andy receives a text reading '911' from someone, panics, calls it urgent — cut to the gym trainer trying to motivate a downbeat man: 'Look, I'm not down anymore, so if the guys start making fun of you, you've just gotta stand up for yourself.'
Andy · Dwight: Andy and Dwight decide they need proof — 'I need, like, a printer to catch on fire.' Dwight: 'I can videotape it.' Andy: 'Yeah.' Beat. 'There it is.'
Michael: Michael looking at Pam's phone photo of Donna with another man: 'Who the hell is this? Who is this guy? Lowest of the low, that guy. Just a notch above Toby.'
Gabe: Gabe's corporate response to the printer fire crisis: hands Andy a coupon — 'That's good for five bucks at Dunkin' Donuts. Any Dunkin' Donuts.'
Gabe Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement ★ Rewatch Gabe · Andy: Gabe rewards Andy's safety report with a Dunkin' Donuts gift card: 'That's good for five bucks at Dunkin' Donuts. Any Dunkin' Donuts.'
Gabe Andy Deadpan/Understatement Irony/Sarcasm Andy: Andy tries to schedule plans with someone; they keep being unavailable — until Andy invents a fake concert: 'Spice Girls are opening for Weird Al. Front row.'
Andy Character Comedy Absurdist Andy: Andy's whistleblower video — he introduces himself formally: 'My name is Andrew Baines Bernard and if you're watching this, it's because I've turned state's witness, because I'm in danger, because I know too much.'
Andy Character Comedy Meta/Self-Referential Dwight · Andy: Dwight tells Andy he should speak in a higher voice because the camera makes him sound weird — Andy adjusts increasingly higher until speaking in a squeaky tone
Dwight Andy Physical/Slapstick Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Andy · Darryl: Andy introduces Darryl on the whistleblower video: 'This is my partner, Darryl Philbin. He's been my partner through this entire thing.' Darryl's confessional: 'I don't want to prank anymore. Things get real. I'm going to stay in my room, go to church, try to do one nice thing per day.'
Andy Darryl Irony/Sarcasm Character Comedy ★ Rewatch Callback Michael: The spin class scene: Michael takes over from the instructor — 'You're no leader. Up, out of your seat! Let's blast!' — 'If they catch us, they will rape us. Go for the cliff. And three, two, one, jump!' — then assesses casualties: 'You're dead, you're dead, you're dead. Good jump. You're barely alive.'
Michael Character Comedy Escalation ★ Rewatch Michael: The spin class instructor competing with Michael to lead the class — 'No! The hill's a trap. Let's take the dirt road off to the side.' / 'If they catch us, they will rape us. Go for the cliff. And three, two, one, jump!'
Michael Character Comedy Absurdist ★ Rewatch Michael: Michael adjudicating spin class survival: 'You're dead, you're dead, you're dead. Good jump.' Then immediately pivoting to 'Okay, now, nice cool-down. Check your pulse rate.'
Michael Character Comedy Deadpan/Understatement Callback Top Episodes — The Office